top of page

Improving Clay Soil in London, Ontario: Compost, Topsoil, Not Sand

4 days ago
6 min read

The best way to improve clay soil in London, Ontario is to add organic matter, mainly compost, again and again over time. Pair it with a layer of good topsoil where you're starting a new lawn or garden bed. Don't add sand. Mixing sand into clay can make it denser and harder, closer to brick than loam. Combine organic matter with less tilling and less traffic on wet soil, and clay becomes one of the most fertile soils you can grow in.


Here's why clay behaves the way it does, what works, what doesn't, and how to plan soil improvements around Ontario's seasons.


Why London Has So Much Clay


Much of London and the surrounding area of Middlesex and Elgin counties has clay or clay-loam soils. Builders often strip topsoil during construction and leave compacted subsoil behind, so many newer subdivisions have only a thin layer of topsoil over dense clay. That's a big reason lawns in new neighbourhoods struggle, and why yards stay soggy after rain.


What Makes Clay Soil Difficult


Clay particles are extremely small and flat. They pack tightly together, which leads to:


  • Slow drainage: water sits on the surface or in the root zone.

  • Compaction: foot traffic, mowers and machines squeeze out air spaces.

  • Hard, cracked ground in summer: clay shrinks as it dries.

  • Late spring warming: wet clay warms slowly, which delays growth.


Clay also has real strengths. It holds nutrients and moisture well. The goal isn't to get rid of clay, but to improve its structure so air and water can move through it.


Why Adding Sand to Clay Doesn't Work


It seems logical that sand would loosen clay. In practice it usually does the opposite. The University of Saskatchewan's gardening program explains that large sand particles mixed with tiny clay particles can result in "a concrete-like mixture." It notes that it takes adding about 50% of the total soil volume to meaningfully change clay's texture. For a typical yard, that's an enormous amount of material.


A few bags or a thin layer of sand won't help, and it may make drainage worse.


What Works: Organic Matter


Compost and other organic matter help clay particles clump into larger crumbs. That opens space for air, water and roots, and it feeds the soil life that keeps improving structure over time.


Good options include:


  • Finished compost: the most reliable amendment. Spread it on beds and lawns every year.

  • Arborist wood chip mulch on beds: as it breaks down, it adds organic matter from the top. The University of Saskatchewan suggests about 4 inches of arborist wood chips on beds.

  • Grass clippings and mulched leaves: free organic matter returned to the lawn.

  • Quality topsoil or triple mix: adds a better growing layer where you're building a new bed or lawn.


How to Improve Clay Soil, Step by Step


  1. Test first. A soil test shows pH and nutrients, so you only add what's needed. See our fall soil testing guide.

  2. Fix the drainage. Amendments can't fix water that runs toward the house or collects in low spots. Grade and drain first.

  3. Stop working wet soil. Digging or driving on wet clay destroys its structure. Wait until a handful crumbles instead of smearing.

  4. Add compost on top. On existing beds, spread 2 to 5 cm (about 1 to 2 inches) each year. Worms and roots will work it in.

  5. Topdress lawns. Spread a thin layer of screened compost or topsoil mix after aerating. Our post on topdressing your lawn explains how.

  6. Build up new areas. For new lawns or gardens, loosen the clay surface, then add a layer of quality topsoil before sodding or planting.

  7. Mulch beds. Keep a layer of mulch on garden beds to protect the soil and add organic matter as it breaks down.

  8. Repeat every year. Soil improvement is a habit, not a one-time job.


Green leafy plants growing in dark, rich garden soil

Comparison: Clay Soil Amendments at a Glance


  • Compost: improves structure, drainage and fertility. Recommended every year.

  • Topsoil: adds a new growing layer, best for new lawns and beds.

  • Wood chip mulch: adds organic matter slowly on beds. Keep it away from tree trunks.

  • Sand: not recommended in small amounts, because it can make clay denser.

  • Gypsum: often marketed for clay. Results depend on soil chemistry, so test before you buy.


Lawns on Clay: Extra Tips


Lawns are where most London homeowners feel the clay problem. A few habits make a big difference:


  • Core aerate compacted lawns in early fall or spring. Pulling plugs opens channels for air and water, and it's the perfect time to topdress.

  • Water deeply and less often. Clay holds water, so frequent light watering keeps the surface soggy and roots shallow.

  • Mow high. Taller grass shades the soil and grows deeper roots.

  • Keep heavy traffic off wet lawns. Park trailers and run equipment only when the ground is firm.

  • Choose suitable grass. Blends with tall fescue or Kentucky bluegrass tend to handle southwestern Ontario conditions well.


Raised Beds: A Shortcut for Vegetable Gardens


If you want a productive vegetable or flower garden this coming season, a raised bed is the fastest route. Instead of waiting years for compost to transform the clay, you build a frame and fill it with a quality soil blend. Roots grow in loose, rich soil while the clay underneath slowly improves. A few tips:


  • Loosen the clay at the bottom of the bed with a fork so water can drain down.

  • Use a blend made for gardens, such as triple mix, rather than straight topsoil.

  • Keep beds at least 20 to 30 cm deep for most vegetables.

  • Top up with compost each spring, because the soil level drops as organic matter breaks down.


Common Mistakes on Clay Soil


  • Rototilling every spring. It feels productive, but it breaks down structure and can form a hard layer just below the tilled zone.

  • Working soil too early. Digging in a wet April compacts clay into clods that last all summer.

  • Spreading a thin skin of topsoil over hard clay. A few centimetres over compacted ground creates a layer that water can't move through. Loosen the clay first.

  • Using sand or fine gravel as a fix. As noted above, small amounts often make things worse.

  • Ignoring drainage. No amendment can fix a yard that slopes toward the house.


Signs Your Clay Soil Is Improving


Improving clay is gradual, but you'll notice changes within a season or two:


  • Puddles drain faster after rain.

  • A shovel goes in more easily, and soil breaks into crumbs.

  • You see more earthworms when you dig.

  • The surface cracks less in summer.

  • Plants and grass root more deeply and need less watering.


How Much Topsoil Do You Need?


For a new lawn over clay, many landscapers aim for roughly 10 to 15 cm of quality topsoil over a loosened, graded base. Garden beds benefit from more. Use our material calculators to estimate cubic yards. Our guide on judging bulk topsoil quality explains what to look for when it's delivered.


When to Improve Clay Soil in Ontario


  • Late fall: spread compost on beds and leave it to settle over winter. This works well in November, before the ground freezes.

  • Spring: wait until the soil dries enough to crumble. Working wet clay in April can undo years of improvement.

  • Early fall: the best time to topdress, overseed and lay sod on improved soil.


Avoid heavy digging or tilling when clay is wet, in any season.


FAQ


Can I add sand to clay soil to improve drainage?


It's not recommended. Small amounts of sand can make clay denser. Research cited by the University of Saskatchewan says it would take about 50% of the soil volume to change clay's texture.


What is the best amendment for clay soil?


Compost is the most reliable choice. Add it every year to beds and as a topdressing on lawns, and combine it with good drainage and less compaction.


How deep should topsoil be over clay for a new lawn?


Roughly 10 to 15 cm of quality topsoil over a loosened, graded clay base works for most new lawns in southwestern Ontario.


Should I rototill clay soil?


Avoid repeated rototilling. It breaks down soil structure and can create a compacted layer below the tilled zone. Adding compost on top works better over time.


When is clay soil too wet to work?


Squeeze a handful. If it forms a sticky ribbon or smears, it's too wet. If it crumbles, it's ready to work.


Order Topsoil and Compost-Rich Mixes


SPM Landscape & Excavation has delivered landscape materials around London since 2006. We're WSIB covered and carry $1M in liability insurance. Browse our topsoil, call (519) 474-0008, email spmlandscape@gmail.com, or visit us at 791 Manchester Rd, London ON.


Comments


(519) 474-0008

©2022 by S.P.M Landscape

bottom of page