Fill Dirt vs. Topsoil in Ontario: Which One Your Project Needs
Fill dirt is subsoil with little organic matter, used to raise grade, fill holes and support structures because it compacts well and does not break down. Topsoil is the dark, organic-rich layer that grows grass and plants, and it goes on top in a layer only as deep as roots need. Most yard projects use both: fill below for bulk and shape, topsoil above for growing.
Ordering the wrong one is a common and costly mistake. Topsoil used as deep fill settles and can trap water, and fill dirt used for a lawn grows poor grass. SPM Landscape & Excavation has delivered and spread soil around London since 2006. Here is how to choose.
What Is Fill Dirt?
Fill dirt usually comes from below the topsoil layer on excavation sites. It can be clay, sand, silt or a mix, often with some stones.
Low organic matter, so it does not rot or shrink much over time.
Compacts well in layers when moisture is right.
Holds shape under loads like patios, sheds and driveways.
Poor for plants because it lacks nutrients and structure for roots.
Clean fill
"Clean fill" means soil free of construction debris, garbage, asphalt, contaminants and large organic material like stumps. Always ask where fill comes from. Unknown fill can bring buried debris, invasive plant roots or contamination onto your property.
What Is Topsoil?
Topsoil is the upper layer of soil where most biological activity happens.
Rich in organic matter, which feeds plants and holds moisture.
Loose structure that roots can grow through.
Settles over time as organic matter breaks down.
Not structural. It should not go under patios, footings or driveways.
Screened topsoil has had stones, roots and clumps removed, which makes it easier to spread and grade for sod or seed. Our post on judging bulk topsoil quality explains what to look for at delivery.

Fill Dirt vs. Topsoil: Side-by-Side Checklist
Purpose: fill builds up height and supports loads. Topsoil grows plants.
Organic content: fill is low. Topsoil is high.
Compaction: fill compacts and stays put. Topsoil settles as it breaks down.
Where it goes: fill goes deep, below the root zone. Topsoil goes on the surface.
Typical uses for fill: pool fill-ins, raising low areas, building up grade near foundations, backfilling trenches.
Typical uses for topsoil: new lawns, garden beds, top layer over fill, topdressing.
Where Each One Belongs
Filling in a pool
Pool fill-ins use clean fill placed and compacted in layers, then a final layer of topsoil for grass. Organic material deep in the hole would decay and leave a sinking yard. Our pool removal FAQ covers fill and compaction questions.
Regrading for drainage
When you need to raise soil next to a house so water flows away, the bulk of the raise is usually fill, with topsoil on top. Never bury siding or bring soil above the foundation's intended finished grade.
New lawns
For sod or seed, spread topsoil over a loosened, graded base. A layer of roughly 10 to 15 cm of quality topsoil gives grass room to root in most yards.
Garden beds
Use topsoil or a blend like triple mix. Fill has no place in a planting bed.
Under hardscape
Patios, walkways and driveways use a compacted granular base, not topsoil or general fill. Remove topsoil from under any hardscape area before building the base.
How Much Should You Order?
Measure the length, width and average depth of the area, then convert to cubic yards or cubic metres. Our landscape materials calculators do the math for you. Add a little extra for settling and uneven ground, and remember that loose material compacts once it is spread and rolled.
Ontario Rules on Moving Soil
Excess soil regulation
Ontario regulates how excess soil is managed under O. Reg. 406/19, On-Site and Excess Soil Management. A 2023 Ministry of the Environment resource sheet on low-risk sites explains that reuse planning requirements, such as filing a notice in the online Excess Soil Registry or mandatory sampling and analysis, do not apply to excess soil from low-risk properties, which include residential, parkland, institutional, agricultural and rural properties. Other rules, such as soil storage and quality, can still apply. Larger and higher-risk projects have more obligations, so builders and developers should check the regulation directly.
Conservation authority fill rules
Placing fill in a floodplain, valley, wetland or shoreline area regulated by a conservation authority usually needs a permit, even on private land. In the London area that is mainly the Upper Thames River Conservation Authority. Our post on conservation authority permits explains how to check.
Neighbour drainage
Raising your yard can send water onto a neighbour's lot. Plan grades so runoff goes to swales, the street or your own lawn areas, not over the property line.
How to Place and Compact Fill Properly
Fill only performs well if it goes in right. Dumping a full load into a hole and spreading topsoil over it leads to settlement, sometimes years later.
Strip organic material first. Remove sod, roots and topsoil from the area being filled so nothing rots underneath.
Place in lifts. Spread fill in thin layers rather than all at once. Thinner layers compact more evenly.
Compact each layer. Use a plate compactor, roller or the weight of equipment, depending on the job size.
Watch moisture. Fill that is too dry will not bind, and fill that is too wet turns to mud and will not compact. Clay is especially sensitive.
Finish with topsoil. Once fill reaches the planned subgrade, spread topsoil to the final grade.
Check drainage. Confirm that water will run away from buildings before sod or seed goes down.
Large or structural fills, such as under a building addition, may need engineered fill and compaction testing. Ask your builder or engineer.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Using topsoil as deep fill in a hole or pool.
Using fill dirt as the growing layer for a new lawn.
Accepting free fill from an unknown source.
Dumping a full load in one spot without compacting in layers.
Building patios on topsoil instead of a granular base.
Raising soil against siding or above window wells.
Winter Ordering Tips
November and December are a good time to plan spring soil deliveries. Frozen or saturated ground can limit where trucks can dump, so choose a firm, accessible drop spot on a driveway or tarp. Topsoil left uncovered over winter can get wet and heavy, so it is usually best to schedule delivery close to when you will spread it.
FAQ
Can I use topsoil as fill dirt?
It is not recommended for deep fills. Topsoil contains organic matter that breaks down and settles, which can leave dips. Use clean fill for bulk and topsoil only for the top growing layer.
How deep should topsoil be for a new lawn?
Roughly 10 to 15 cm of quality topsoil over a loosened, graded base works for most new lawns.
Is fill dirt good for growing grass?
No. Fill has little organic matter or nutrients. Cover it with a layer of topsoil before seeding or sodding.
Do I need a permit to bring fill onto my property in Ontario?
Usually not for small residential jobs outside regulated areas, but fill in a conservation authority regulated area normally needs a permit. Larger projects may also have obligations under O. Reg. 406/19.
What is clean fill?
Clean fill is soil free of construction debris, garbage, asphalt, contamination and large organic material. Always ask the supplier where it came from.
Order Fill or Topsoil in London
SPM Landscape & Excavation delivers screened topsoil and other bulk materials across London and area, and we can spread and grade it too. See our topsoil page, call (519) 474-0008 or email spmlandscape@gmail.com.




Comments