top of page

Natural Stone vs. Concrete Pavers for Ontario Patios

4 days ago
5 min read

Both natural stone and concrete pavers make durable patios in Ontario. Concrete pavers offer consistent sizes, lots of colours and easy replacement, and they are made to a Canadian standard for freeze-thaw durability. Natural stone gives a unique, high-end look and can last for generations, but it varies more piece to piece and usually costs more to buy and install. Either one fails early if the base underneath is poor.


Winter is the right time to make this decision, so your design and quote are ready before spring booking fills up. SPM Landscape & Excavation has built hardscapes around London since 2006. Here is how to compare.


What Are Concrete Pavers?


Concrete pavers, often called interlock in Ontario, are factory-made units of concrete pressed into moulds. They come in many shapes, from classic rectangles to large-format slabs and textured tumbled styles.


  • Consistent size and thickness, which makes installation faster and joints tighter.

  • Wide colour and texture range, including finishes that imitate natural stone.

  • Made to a standard. In Canada, precast concrete pavers are typically produced to CSA A231.2, which includes freeze-thaw durability testing in salt solution.

  • Easy to repair. Individual pavers lift out and go back if you need to fix a spot.


What Is Natural Stone?


Natural stone patios use quarried rock, cut or split into slabs and pieces. Common choices in Ontario include:


  • Flagstone: irregular or cut slabs of sedimentary stone, often limestone or sandstone.

  • Armour stone and steps: large blocks for walls and steps, often paired with flagstone patios.

  • Granite and other hard stones: very dense and durable, often as cut pavers or setts.

  • Bluestone and sandstone: cut slabs with a natural, layered look.


Each type behaves differently. Dense stones like granite resist wear and absorption well. Softer, layered stones can flake or split if water gets in and freezes.


Hexagonal paving stones forming a pathway through grass

Side-by-Side Comparison


  • Look: concrete pavers look uniform and clean. Natural stone has unique colour and texture variation in every piece.

  • Freeze-thaw durability: pavers made to CSA A231.2 are tested for it. Natural stone durability depends on the stone type and quality.

  • Salt resistance: quality pavers are tested in salt solution. Some natural stones, especially softer or porous types, can be damaged by de-icing salt.

  • Installation: pavers go down faster because sizes are uniform. Irregular stone takes more cutting and fitting, which adds labour.

  • Repairs: pavers are easy to swap. Matching a specific natural stone later can be harder.

  • Cost factors: natural stone material and labour usually cost more. Actual prices depend on the product, site and design, so get a free quote.

  • Lifespan: both can last decades with a proper base and care.


The Base Matters More Than the Surface


In London's clay soils and freeze-thaw winters, most patio failures start below the surface. Heaving, sinking and shifting come from a thin base, poor compaction or water trapped under the patio.


A durable patio base generally includes:


  1. Excavation below the frost-active topsoil and soft material, after free utility locates through Ontario Dig Authority (formerly Ontario One Call).

  2. Geotextile fabric on clay subgrade where needed, to keep layers separate.

  3. Compacted granular base placed and compacted in lifts.

  4. Bedding layer of fine aggregate, screeded smooth.

  5. Slope away from the house so water drains off.

  6. Edge restraint to stop units creeping outward.


Our guide to interlock base prep that survives freeze-thaw goes through each layer. If you want to understand why patios lift in winter, read our post on frost heave.


Dry-laid vs. mortar-set stone


Natural stone can be dry-laid on a granular base or set in mortar on a concrete slab. Dry-laid installations flex with the ground and are easier to repair. Mortar-set stone looks very refined but can crack in freeze-thaw if the slab underneath moves.


Salt and Winter Care


De-icing salt is hard on many hardscape surfaces. To protect your patio:


  • Use salt sparingly and only where people walk.

  • Shovel early so less ice forms.

  • Use sand or grit for traction on very cold days when salt works poorly.

  • Sweep up leftover salt and grit in spring.


Our article on protecting interlock and concrete from salt has more winter tips.


Maintenance Over Time


Concrete pavers


  • Top up joint sand or polymeric sand as it washes out.

  • Pull weeds from joints early.

  • Reset any sunken or lifted pavers.

  • Sealing is optional and can deepen colour.


Natural stone


  • Refill joints with sand or stone dust.

  • Remove moss in shady areas.

  • Check for flaking or cracked pieces after winter.

  • Some stones benefit from sealing. Ask your supplier about your stone type.


Design Tips for London Patios


A good patio is about more than the surface material. Before you pick stone or pavers, think about how the space will work:


  • Size it for furniture. Lay out your table, chairs or lounge set and leave room to walk around them.

  • Plan for a fire pit or grill. Heat-resistant materials and safe clearances belong in the design from the start.

  • Think about sun and shade. Pale surfaces stay cooler in full sun. Dark surfaces warm up fast.

  • Connect to the house. Steps from a deck or patio door should be easy and safe to use in all seasons.

  • Handle the water. Every patio sheds rain. Plan where that water goes, especially on clay lots.

  • Leave room for planting. Beds along the edges soften the look and help absorb runoff.


If drainage is a concern on your lot, our post on permeable pavers on clay soil explains when they make sense.


Which One Should You Choose?


Pick concrete pavers if you want:


  • A clean, uniform look or a modern large-format slab

  • Faster installation and easier repairs

  • Strong freeze-thaw and salt performance from a tested product


Pick natural stone if you want:


  • A one-of-a-kind, natural look

  • Material that pairs with armour stone walls or steps

  • A long-term, premium feature and you are comfortable with a higher budget


Many patios combine both: concrete pavers for the main area and natural stone for steps, borders or a feature wall. Mixing materials lets you put your budget where it shows most, such as a natural stone landing at the back door, while keeping the larger seating area practical and easy to maintain.


FAQ


Is natural stone or concrete pavers better for Ontario winters?


Both can handle Ontario winters with a proper base. Concrete pavers made to CSA A231.2 are tested for freeze-thaw durability in salt solution. Natural stone varies by type, so choose a dense, durable stone for exposed areas.


Which costs more, natural stone or concrete pavers?


Natural stone usually costs more in material and labour, especially irregular flagstone that needs custom fitting. Prices vary by product and site, so get a free quote.


Can I use salt on a natural stone patio?


Use as little as possible. Some softer or porous stones can be damaged by salt. Shovel early and use sand or grit for traction when it is very cold.


How long do paver patios last in Ontario?


A well-built patio with a properly compacted base can last decades. Most problems come from a poor base or drainage, not the surface material.


When should I book a patio for spring?


Late fall and winter are good times to get designs and quotes, so your project can be scheduled as soon as the ground is ready in spring.


Plan Your Spring Patio


Ready to compare options for your yard? SPM Landscape & Excavation builds patios, walkways and driveways in London and across southwestern Ontario. See our work in the photo gallery, call (519) 474-0008 or email spmlandscape@gmail.com.


Comments


(519) 474-0008

©2022 by S.P.M Landscape

bottom of page