top of page

How to Judge Bulk Topsoil Quality Before It's Delivered

Oct 26
5 min read

Good bulk topsoil is dark, crumbly and screened, with no stones, roots, garbage or chunks of clay, and it should smell earthy rather than sour. The best way to judge it is to ask your supplier what it's made of and where it comes from, look at a sample before you order, and inspect the load as soon as it's dumped. A few minutes of checking can save you from spreading weeds, rubble or heavy clay across your yard.


Topsoil is the foundation of every lawn, garden and sod job. This guide explains what quality topsoil looks like, which questions to ask, and how to check a load when it arrives at your London home.


Why Topsoil Quality Matters


Topsoil is the layer your grass and plants actually live in. Poor topsoil causes problems that are hard to fix once it's spread:


  • Weeds: Soil full of weed seeds or roots brings new weeds to your lawn or garden.

  • Poor drainage: Topsoil with too much clay can seal up, especially over London's native clay.

  • Debris: Stones, glass, plastic and construction waste make soil hard to work and can damage equipment.

  • Weak growth: Low organic matter or poor structure means shallow roots and a lawn that struggles in summer.

  • Settling: Soil with lots of undecomposed material shrinks as it breaks down.


What Good Topsoil Looks Like


Colour


Good topsoil is usually dark brown to near black, which often points to organic matter. Very light, grey or orange soil may be subsoil. Colour alone isn't proof of quality, though, since some soils are naturally lighter.


Texture


Rub a moist handful between your fingers. Quality topsoil feels crumbly and slightly gritty, and it holds together loosely when squeezed but breaks apart when poked. If it forms a hard, shiny ribbon, it's high in clay. If it won't hold together at all, it may be mostly sand.


Screening


Screened topsoil has been passed through a mesh to remove stones, roots, sticks and clumps. For lawns, sod and seeding, screened soil is much easier to grade and rake smooth.


Smell


Healthy soil smells earthy. A sour, rotten-egg or chemical smell can be a sign that the soil was stockpiled wet with no air, or that something has contaminated it.


Cleanliness


There should be no visible garbage, glass, plastic, asphalt, concrete chunks or treated wood.


Close-up of dark brown screened topsoil

Questions to Ask Your Supplier


Before you order, ask:


  1. Is it screened, and through what size of screen?

  2. Where does the soil come from? Reputable suppliers know their sources.

  3. Is it straight topsoil or a blend? Many products are blended with compost or sand. That's not a bad thing, but you should know what you're getting.

  4. Can I see it first? A supplier with a yard should let you see the pile.

  5. Has it been stored properly? Soil stockpiled for a long time can lose structure or grow weeds on top.

  6. What do you recommend for my project? Lawns, sod, gardens and grading can each call for a different product.


Ontario's excess soil regulation (O. Reg. 406/19) governs how soil from construction projects is moved and reused. A supplier who can explain where its soil comes from is a good sign.


Common Topsoil Problems and What Causes Them


Most bad loads fall into a few categories. Knowing the cause helps you spot them:


  • Subsoil sold as topsoil: Soil from deeper in an excavation is lighter in colour, low in organic matter and often heavy in clay. It may look clean but grows poor grass.

  • Unscreened soil: Soil that hasn't been screened carries stones, sod chunks and roots that make raking and grading difficult.

  • Weedy stockpiles: A pile left uncovered for a season can grow a crop of weeds, and their seeds end up mixed through the soil.

  • Wet, airless soil: Soil stockpiled while saturated can turn sour and lose its crumbly structure.

  • Mixed fill: Soil mixed with brick, asphalt or concrete from a construction site is fill, not topsoil.


Topsoil Quality Checklist


Use this checklist when your load arrives:


  • Dark and evenly coloured, without streaks of grey or orange subsoil

  • Crumbly texture, not sticky clay lumps

  • Screened, with no stones larger than small gravel

  • No roots, sod chunks or sticks

  • No garbage, glass, plastic, concrete or asphalt

  • Earthy smell

  • Not soaking wet or frozen

  • Matches what you ordered and saw at the yard


If the load fails on obvious points such as debris or heavy clay, call the supplier before you spread any of it.


How to Check a Load When It Arrives


When the truck dumps your soil, take a few minutes before you start spreading:


  1. Look at the whole pile. Walk around it and check for debris on the surface.

  2. Dig into it. Push a shovel into a few spots and pull out a sample from the middle, not just the outside.

  3. Do the squeeze test. Squeeze a handful. It should crumble, not form a hard ball.

  4. Check the moisture. Wet soil is heavier, harder to spread and clumps.

  5. Take photos. If there's a problem, photos help when you talk to your supplier.


Make sure your delivery spot is ready before the truck shows up. Our guide to preparing your property for bulk delivery covers access, placement and protecting your driveway.


Spreading Topsoil the Right Way


Even great topsoil can disappoint if it's spread badly. A few tips:


  1. Loosen the existing surface first so the new soil bonds with what's underneath instead of sitting as a separate layer.

  2. Spread in even passes and rake to a smooth grade that slopes away from your house.

  3. Avoid driving heavy equipment over the spread soil, which compacts it.

  4. Firm the surface lightly with a roller before seeding or laying sod.

  5. Water after seeding or sodding to settle the soil.


Topsoil vs. Blends: Which Do You Need?


  • Lawn repair and seeding: Screened topsoil or a soil-compost blend gives seed a fine, even bed.

  • New sod: Screened topsoil spread and graded evenly. See our sod page.

  • Gardens and planters: A richer blend with more organic matter.

  • Grading and filling low areas: Screened topsoil on top of a suitable fill base.

  • Topdressing: Fine, screened material, often a compost blend.


To work out how much you need, read how much topsoil, mulch or gravel to order or use our landscape calculators.


Late-Fall Delivery in London


Late fall is a good time to get topsoil in place for spring projects, but plan around the weather:


  • Order before the ground freezes so the truck can reach your drop spot without rutting the lawn.

  • Cover the pile with a tarp to keep out rain, snow and windblown weed seeds.

  • Avoid spreading soil that's frozen or saturated.

  • Leave the pile where it won't block snow clearing.


FAQ


What does good topsoil look like?


It's usually dark brown to near black, crumbly, screened and free of stones, roots and debris, with an earthy smell. It should hold together loosely when squeezed and break apart easily.


What is screened topsoil?


Screened topsoil has been passed through a mesh screen to remove stones, roots, sticks and clumps. It's easier to spread and grade, and it's the usual choice for lawns, sod and seeding.


How can I tell if topsoil has too much clay?


Rub moist soil between your fingers. If it feels sticky and forms a long, shiny ribbon, it's high in clay. Soil with heavy clay can seal over and drain poorly.


What should I do if my topsoil delivery has debris in it?


Don't spread it. Take photos and contact your supplier right away. Reputable suppliers will address problems with a load.


Can I store topsoil over the winter?


Yes. Keep the pile on a level spot away from drains, cover it with a tarp and keep it clear of snow-clearing routes. Spread it in spring once it has thawed and dried.


Order Quality Topsoil From SPM


SPM Landscape & Excavation delivers screened topsoil, mulch and gravel across London and southwestern Ontario from our yard at 791 Manchester Rd. We've been in business since 2006. Call (519) 474-0008 or email spmlandscape@gmail.com to place an order.


Comments


(519) 474-0008

©2022 by S.P.M Landscape

bottom of page