Stump Grinding vs. Stump Removal: Which Is Right for Your Yard?
Stump grinding chews the stump down below ground level and leaves the roots to rot in place, while stump removal pulls out the stump and its main roots. Grinding is usually faster, less disruptive and the right choice for most lawns and gardens; full removal makes sense when you're building, digging or planting right where the tree stood. In London, check the Tree Protection By-law and book utility locates before either one.
A leftover stump is more than an eyesore. It gets in the way of mowing, can sprout new shoots, and may attract insects and fungi. This guide compares the two options and explains what London homeowners need to check before work starts.
Signs a Stump Needs Attention
Some stumps can sit for years without causing trouble. Others create problems quickly. Deal with a stump sooner if you notice:
New shoots or suckers growing from the stump or roots
Mushrooms, fungus or soft, crumbling wood
Ants, beetles or other insects moving into the wood
A trip hazard in a lawn, play area or walkway
Roots lifting a walkway, patio or driveway edge
A stump in the way of mowing, grading or a planned project
How Stump Grinding Works
A stump grinder uses a spinning wheel with carbide teeth to chip away the stump, a little at a time. The operator sweeps the wheel back and forth until the stump is below the surface.
The stump is ground into a pile of wood chips and soil.
The main roots below the grinding depth are left in the ground to decay.
Surface roots that run across the lawn can often be ground as well.
The hole is filled with the grindings or with topsoil.
Grinders come in different sizes. Compact machines can fit through a backyard gate, while larger ones handle big stumps faster.
How Stump Removal Works
Full stump removal means digging out the stump and its main root mass. It's usually done with an excavator, which can lever the stump out of the ground once the roots around it are exposed and cut.
The stump and major roots are removed whole.
A large hole is left behind and must be backfilled and compacted.
More soil gets disturbed around the stump.
The stump and roots have to be hauled away.
Grinding vs. Removal: Side-by-Side
Disruption: Grinding disturbs a small area. Removal digs a much larger hole and may rut the lawn with equipment.
Roots: Grinding leaves deeper roots to rot. Removal takes out the main root mass.
Access: Small grinders fit through gates. Removal usually needs an excavator and more room.
Debris: Grinding leaves chips that can be used or hauled away. Removal leaves a stump and roots to dispose of.
Future use: Grinding is fine for lawn, sod and most gardens. Removal is better before foundations, pools, patios or utility work in the same spot.
Settling: Ground-out holes may sink as roots and chips decay. Removal holes settle too unless they're backfilled and compacted in layers.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose stump grinding if:
You plan to put lawn, sod or a garden bed over the spot
The stump is near a house, fence, driveway or other structure you don't want disturbed
Access is tight
You want a quick, tidy result
Choose full stump removal if:
You're building a deck, shed, addition, patio or pool in that spot
You need to dig a trench or install drainage through the area
You're clearing a lot for construction
A cluster of stumps and roots has to come out for grading

London Rules to Check First
The Tree Protection By-law
The City of London's Tree Protection By-law (C.P.-1555-252) requires a permit to injure or destroy a Distinctive Tree, which the by-law defines as a tree with a trunk diameter of 50 cm or more measured 1.4 m above ground, within the Urban Growth Boundary. It also protects trees of any size in mapped Tree Protection Areas.
If the tree is still standing, you'll need to sort out the permit before it comes down. The by-law's definition of "destroy" includes uprooting, so if a protected tree's stump is part of the work, confirm with the City before removing it. Exemptions and permit rules are detailed in the by-law. Our article on tree pruning and removal in London covers timing and permits for standing trees.
Utility locates
Both grinding and removal dig into the ground, and tree roots often wrap around buried gas lines, water services and cables. Book free locates through Ontario One Call, now operating as the Ontario Dig Authority. Ontario municipalities note that utility owners have up to five business days to complete a standard single-address request, so plan ahead.
Boulevard and city trees
Trees on the city boulevard are usually the City's responsibility. Don't grind or remove a stump on city property without checking with the City first.
What to Do After the Stump Is Gone
The work isn't finished when the stump disappears. To get a clean, level yard:
Remove or spread the grindings. Chips can be used as mulch elsewhere, but don't leave a big mound where you want grass.
Fill the hole with topsoil. Wood chips break down and settle, so replacing most of them with screened topsoil gives a firmer surface. See our topsoil page.
Allow for settling. Top up the spot after a few weeks or the next spring.
Seed or sod. Once the soil is level, seed or lay sod. Our sod page explains our sod work.
Watch for sprouts. Some species send up shoots from leftover roots. Cut them off as they appear.
Dead Ash Trees and Storm Damage
Emerald ash borer has killed many ash trees across London, and many homeowners are now dealing with the stumps. Dead ash wood can become brittle, so the tree itself should be taken down carefully by a professional. Our guide to removing dead ash trees safely explains the risks.
Questions to Ask Your Contractor
Before you book stump work, ask:
Will you grind or remove the stump, and why?
How deep will you grind, and will surface roots be included?
What happens to the grindings or the stump afterward?
Will you backfill with topsoil, and is seeding or sod included?
Who books the utility locates?
How will you protect the lawn, fences and gardens from equipment?
Are you covered by WSIB, and do you carry liability insurance?
Late Fall Timing
Stump grinding can be done most of the year, as long as the ground isn't deeply frozen and the site is accessible. Late fall works well because gardens are cut back and lawns are dormant. Full removal with an excavator is best done before the ground freezes hard, and it's easier to restore the lawn in spring.
FAQ
Is stump grinding or stump removal better?
For most lawns and gardens, grinding is better because it's quicker and less disruptive. Full removal is better when you're building, digging or installing something right where the tree stood.
Do the roots die after stump grinding?
For most trees, the remaining roots die and slowly decay after the stump is ground out. Some species can sprout from leftover roots, so cut back any shoots that appear.
Can I plant a new tree where a stump was ground?
Usually it's better to plant a little to the side, because the old root system and wood chips take time to break down. If you must use the same spot, remove the chips and replace them with good topsoil.
Do I need a permit to remove a stump in London, Ontario?
The Tree Protection By-law requires permits for Distinctive Trees and trees in Tree Protection Areas, and its definition of "destroy" includes uprooting. If the stump belonged to a protected tree, confirm with the City before removing it.
Do I need locates before stump grinding?
Yes. Grinding and removal both dig into the ground, so book free locates through Ontario One Call, now operating as the Ontario Dig Authority, before work starts.
Get Help With Tree and Stump Work
SPM Landscape & Excavation handles tree trimming, removal, stump work and yard restoration across London and southwestern Ontario. We've been in business since 2006, we're WSIB covered and we carry $1 million in liability insurance. Call (519) 474-0008 or email spmlandscape@gmail.com for a free quote.




Comments