Ice Melt Products for Commercial Lots: Salt vs. Chloride Blends
Rock salt (sodium chloride) is the most common and lowest-cost ice melt for commercial lots, but it works slowly once pavement temperatures drop below about -9°C (15°F). Magnesium chloride and calcium chloride keep working at much colder pavement temperatures, so they are used alone or blended with salt for cold snaps. Sand and grit add traction but never melt ice.
Choosing the right product for each storm keeps lots safer and cuts waste. SPM Landscape & Excavation has provided commercial snow and ice services in London since 2006. Here is how the main options compare.
Pavement Temperature Is What Counts
De-icers respond to the temperature of the pavement, not the air. A sunny afternoon can warm asphalt above air temperature, while a clear night can make pavement colder than the air. University of Minnesota's Smart Winter Salt guide for property managers recommends checking pavement temperature and switching to a cold-weather product when it falls below about -9°C.
An infrared thermometer or a pavement sensor on a plow truck is a simple way to check before treating.
How Ice Melt Works
Ice melt products dissolve into a brine that lowers the freezing point of water. That brine works its way under ice and snow, breaking the bond with the pavement so plows and shovels can clear it. The colder it is, the slower this happens, until the product stops working altogether.
Two temperatures matter:
Lowest practical temperature: the point where the product still works fast enough to be useful.
Eutectic temperature: the lowest point where it can melt anything at all, but very slowly.
Plan around the practical temperature.
Product Comparison
The figures below come from the Minnesota Stormwater Manual and University of Minnesota guidance, converted to Celsius and rounded.
Rock salt (sodium chloride)
Lowest practical pavement temperature: about -9°C (15°F).
Pros: lowest cost, widely available, effective in typical southwestern Ontario winter weather.
Cons: slows down sharply in cold snaps. Dry salt at very low temperatures can bounce or blow away before it melts anything. Chlorides harm plants, soil and waterways and can damage concrete and metal.
Best for: most storms near or a bit below freezing.
Magnesium chloride
Lowest practical pavement temperature: about -23°C (-10°F).
Pros: works in much colder conditions than salt. Often used as a liquid or blended with salt.
Cons: higher cost. Still a chloride, with similar environmental concerns.
Best for: cold snaps and pre-wetting salt to speed it up.
Calcium chloride
Lowest practical pavement temperature: about -29°C (-20°F).
Pros: works at the coldest temperatures of the common chlorides. Releases heat as it dissolves, so it starts working quickly.
Cons: highest cost of the common chlorides. Can leave surfaces slick if over-applied, and it is still a chloride.
Best for: extreme cold, entrances and problem spots.
Calcium magnesium acetate (CMA)
Lowest practical pavement temperature: about -7°C (20°F).
Pros: chloride-free and generally less corrosive.
Cons: much higher cost and weaker in cold weather.
Best for: sensitive areas like new concrete or near structures where corrosion is a concern.
Sand and traction grit
Melting: none. Sand never melts ice.
Pros: gives grip when it is too cold for salt to work.
Cons: washes into catch basins and storm sewers, needs spring sweeping, and is tracked indoors.
Best for: extreme cold and as a short-term traction aid.

Quick Selection Checklist
Pavement around -1°C to -9°C: rock salt, ideally pre-wetted.
Pavement colder than -9°C: switch to a magnesium or calcium chloride blend, or treat salt with liquid chloride.
Extreme cold: calcium chloride at entrances, plus sand or grit for traction.
Before a storm: anti-icing with brine can stop ice from bonding in the first place.
New concrete or sensitive surfaces: use the least corrosive option and follow the supplier's guidance.
Our post on brine anti-icing for commercial lots explains how pre-treating with liquid works.
Use Less, Get Better Results
More product does not mean a safer lot. Over-application wastes money, damages surfaces and landscaping, and ends up in local creeks. Good practices include:
Plow first. Remove as much snow as possible before applying any de-icer.
Calibrate spreaders so you know how much product is going down.
Pre-wet salt so it sticks to the pavement and starts working faster.
Treat where it matters most: entrances, walkways, ramps and drive aisles.
Sweep up leftovers after the storm and reuse where possible.
Keep records of weather, timing and amounts applied.
The Smart About Salt program teaches these practices to Ontario contractors and property managers. Read our guide to Smart About Salt certification for details.
Protecting Surfaces and Landscaping
Chloride de-icers can damage concrete, interlock, metal railings and nearby plants. To limit damage:
Keep salt off lawns and planting beds along lot edges.
Choose salt-tolerant plants near curbs and walkways.
Ask your concrete supplier about protecting new concrete in its first winter.
Wash salt residue off railings and equipment in spring.
Our article on de-icing salt damage covers repairs and prevention.
Liquids vs. Solids
Ice melt comes in two main forms, and many commercial programs use both.
Solid products
Rock salt and treated salt are spread as granules. They work well on existing ice and packed snow, because the granules bore down to the pavement. Solids can bounce and scatter, though, especially from a fast-moving spreader or on bare pavement.
Liquid products
Salt brine and liquid chlorides are sprayed on the pavement. Before a storm, liquids anti-ice the surface so snow and ice do not bond. During cold snaps, liquid chlorides sprayed onto rock salt as it leaves the spreader help it start working faster and stick where it lands.
Treated salt
Some suppliers sell rock salt pre-treated with a liquid chloride or other additive. It costs more than plain salt but works at lower temperatures and can reduce the amount needed.
Building a Product Plan for Your Site
Every commercial site is different. A strip mall, a medical office and a warehouse yard have different traffic, risk and surfaces. A simple plan covers:
Which product to use at each temperature range
Where to apply first, such as entrances, ramps and accessible parking
How much to apply per area, based on spreader calibration
When to switch to traction grit
Who keeps the records
Where Melted Water Goes
All that brine has to drain somewhere. In London, catch basins carry water straight to local waterways without treatment. Keeping basins clear and snow piles away from them helps lots drain and keeps ice from reforming. The Minnesota Stormwater Manual explains how chlorides affect water quality.
FAQ
At what temperature does rock salt stop working?
Rock salt slows down sharply when pavement drops below about -9°C (15°F). It can still melt a little at colder temperatures, but too slowly to be practical for most lots.
Is calcium chloride better than rock salt?
Calcium chloride works at much colder temperatures, around -29°C (-20°F), and starts melting faster. It costs more, so many sites use it only in cold snaps or blend it with salt.
What is the best ice melt for very cold days?
A calcium chloride or magnesium chloride product, or a blend with salt, works best in cold snaps. Add sand or grit for traction when it is too cold for any de-icer to work quickly.
Does sand melt ice?
No. Sand only adds traction. It does not melt ice and must be swept up in spring.
How can commercial lots use less salt?
Plow before treating, calibrate spreaders, pre-wet salt, anti-ice with brine before storms, and treat only the areas that need it. Smart About Salt training covers these practices.
Commercial Snow and Ice Services in London
SPM Landscape & Excavation provides commercial plowing, salting and ice management across London and area. Call (519) 474-0008 or email spmlandscape@gmail.com for a free quote. We are WSIB covered and carry $1 million in liability insurance.




Comments