top of page

Compacting a Filled-In Pool: Lifts, Testing and Building Later

4 days ago
6 min read

If you're filling in an inground pool, the fill has to go in as thin layers called lifts, with each layer compacted before the next one goes on. Dumping it all in at once is the wrong way. A lawn or garden can usually go on top of well-compacted fill. If you might ever build a shed, patio, addition or garage there, plan for engineered fill, compaction testing and paperwork from day one.


That one decision, made before the first truckload arrives, can spare you sinking ground and costly rework later. SPM Landscape & Excavation has been removing and filling pools across London and southwestern Ontario since 2006. This guide covers how compaction works, the choices you'll face and what to ask before your project starts.


Why Compaction Matters After a Pool Fill-In


An inground pool leaves a big void. When that void is filled with loose material, there are air gaps between the soil particles. Over months and years, rain, snowmelt and gravity squeeze those gaps out and the surface drops. In London's freeze-thaw winters, water sitting in loose fill also expands and contracts, which can make settling worse.


Poorly compacted pool fill usually shows up as:


  • A shallow dip or "bathtub" outline in the lawn after the first spring

  • Puddles that sit where the deep end used to be

  • Patio stones or shed pads that tilt or crack

  • Fence posts or edging near the old pool wall that start to lean

  • Soft, spongy ground that ruts when a mower or wheelbarrow crosses it


Proper compaction won't make soil behave like concrete. It greatly reduces how much the surface moves over time, and that is what protects your lawn and anything you build later.


Step 1: Decide What the Area Will Be Used For


Before choosing fill or compaction methods, decide what will sit on top of the old pool. This is the biggest single factor in both cost and process.


Option A: Lawn, Gardens or a Play Area


For grass, garden beds or an open play space, the usual approach is clean fill compacted in lifts and topped with quality topsoil. A little settling is still possible, and a light top-up of topsoil after the first season is normal.


Option B: Future Structures or Hard Surfaces


If a structure, patio or driveway might ever go over the pool area, treat it like a building site. Some Ontario municipalities spell this out. The City of Guelph's pool guidance says that if you plan to build on the site later, "a soils engineer will need to be retained to supervise the filling and compacting process." It also calls for compaction testing in 150 mm lifts, with the reports provided to the City. Rules vary by municipality, so check with your local building department before work starts.


Step 2: Choose the Right Fill Material


Not every pile of dirt is suitable. Here's how the common options compare:


  • Clean granular fill (sand, gravel or granular material): drains well and compacts predictably. It is a common choice when structures may follow.

  • Clean native clay fill: often available and lower in cost. It is harder to compact properly when wet, holds water, and can be slow to stabilize.

  • Topsoil: save it for the top growing layer only. It is high in organic matter that breaks down and shrinks, so it should never fill the bulk of the hole.

  • Mixed debris, voided concrete or "free fill" of unknown origin: avoid it. Unknown fill can contain garbage or contamination, and it can leave pockets that collapse later.


Whatever you use, ask where it came from. Reputable contractors use clean material and can tell you its source.


Step 3: Prepare the Pool Shell


Compaction starts before any fill goes in. For a partial or full removal, basic prep looks like this:


  1. Drain the pool, following your municipality's discharge rules.

  2. Remove the liner, ladders, lights, piping and equipment.

  3. For a partial removal, break up the floor so water drains out of the bottom instead of collecting like a bathtub.

  4. Remove or break down the upper section of the walls, as the chosen method requires.

  5. Remove the coping and any debris that could leave voids.


Our pool removal procedure page walks through how SPM handles each stage on a real job.


Step 4: Place and Compact Fill in Lifts


This is where most DIY and low-bid fill-ins go wrong. Dumping a full load into the deep end and driving a machine over the top only compacts the upper layer, while the bottom stays loose.


The correct approach:


  1. Place fill in thin, even lifts. The right thickness depends on the material and equipment, and an engineer may set it. Guelph's guidance, for example, references testing in 150 mm lifts when building is planned.

  2. Compact each lift with equipment that suits the material: a vibratory plate or smooth roller for granular fill, or a padfoot roller for clay.

  3. Watch the moisture. Soil that is too dry or too wet won't compact well, and saturated clay can turn to mush.

  4. Repeat until the fill reaches subgrade height, leaving room for topsoil.

  5. Finish with screened topsoil, grade it to drain away from the house, then seed or lay sod.


Yellow excavator parked on a grassy lawn near houses during backyard earthwork

Step 5: Compaction Testing (When You Need It)


For lawns and gardens, a visual check and a proof roll with loaded equipment are often enough. For future structures, testing gives you proof. A geotechnical engineer or testing firm measures each lift's density against a lab standard and writes a report.


Keep that report with your property records. It helps if you sell the home, apply for a building permit later, or need to show what's under the lawn. Our post on selling a home with a filled-in pool explains why that paperwork matters.


Common Compaction Mistakes to Avoid


  • Filling in one big pass. Thick layers can't be compacted from the top.

  • Leaving the floor intact on a partial removal. Water gets trapped and the fill stays soft.

  • Compacting frozen or saturated soil. It looks firm, then settles when it thaws or dries.

  • Using topsoil as bulk fill. Organic matter rots and the surface sinks.

  • Skipping grading. A flat or dished finish sends water toward the old pool area and the house.


Checklist: Questions to Ask Your Pool Fill-In Contractor


  • Will the fill be placed and compacted in lifts, and how thick will they be?

  • What fill material will you use, and where does it come from?

  • What compaction equipment will you bring?

  • Will you break the pool floor for drainage on a partial removal?

  • Do you handle the permit, or do I?

  • Can you arrange compaction testing if I want to build later?

  • Are you WSIB covered and insured?

  • How will you protect my lawn, driveway and gate during access?


Can You Compact Pool Fill in Late Fall or Winter?


Frozen soil can't be compacted properly. Fill that freezes between lifts traps frost, which thaws and settles in spring. In London, late-fall jobs can work in dry stretches above freezing. Once the ground and the fill stockpile freeze, most contractors pause backfilling until spring. Booking over the winter is a good way to get onto an early spring schedule.


Local Notes for London and Southwestern Ontario


Much of London sits on heavy clay soil that drains slowly. That makes the drainage step at the bottom of the pool more important, and a clay-only fill can take longer to stabilize. Before any digging, you need a utility locate through Ontario One Call, because gas, hydro or cable lines often run close to pool equipment pads. Permit rules for pool removal and fill-in differ between London, St. Thomas, the Middlesex County townships and Waterloo Region, so check locally or ask us. Our pool removal FAQs cover the questions we hear most.


FAQ


How long does pool fill take to settle?


Well-compacted fill settles very little, but some minor settling in the first year is common, especially with clay. Plan for a light topsoil top-up after the first spring.


Can I build a shed on a filled-in pool?


Possibly, but only if the fill was engineered and compacted under supervision, with test reports. Some municipalities, such as Guelph, require a soils engineer for areas that will be built on. Check with your building department first.


What fill is best for filling in a pool?


Clean granular fill compacts most predictably. Clean clay can work for lawn areas if it is compacted at the right moisture. Never use topsoil for the bulk of the fill.


How thick should each lift of fill be?


It depends on the material and equipment. Engineers often specify thin lifts, and Guelph's guidance references testing in 150 mm lifts when building is planned.


Do I need compaction testing for a lawn?


Usually not. Testing is mainly for areas where a structure, patio or driveway may go in later. For a lawn, proper lifts and the right compaction equipment matter most.


Get a Free Pool Fill-In Quote


SPM Landscape & Excavation has served London and southwestern Ontario since 2006. We're WSIB covered and carry $1M in liability insurance. Call (519) 474-0008, email spmlandscape@gmail.com, or visit us at 791 Manchester Rd, London ON.


Comments


(519) 474-0008

©2022 by S.P.M Landscape

bottom of page